The online car auction landscape has transformed significantly in recent years, with enthusiasts and collectors finding new ways to buy and sell unique vehicles without traditional dealer fees.
Two of the most prominent platforms, Cars & Bids and Bring a Trailer (BaT), offer enthusiasts distinct features tailored to different audiences and preferences. In this article, we’ll compare these two platforms in terms of the types of vehicles they feature, auction experience, fees, community engagement, and overall usability to help you decide which platform may suit your needs.
1. Platform Overview
Cars & Bids is relatively new, launched by automotive YouTuber Doug DeMuro in 2020. It focuses primarily on modern enthusiast cars, specifically vehicles from the 1980s to the present. The platform was designed with the goal of curating cars that car enthusiasts are particularly passionate about, including rare models, unique trims, and enthusiast-loved brands.
Bring a Trailer, on the other hand, has been around since 2007 and has established itself as a go-to platform for classic and collector cars of all eras. The platform is known for hosting a mix of older classics, vintage cars, and some modern collectibles. BaT’s auctions cover a wide range, from high-end classics to quirky cars with cult followings.
2. Auction Format and Experience
Both platforms follow an auction model, but there are subtle differences:
- Cars & Bids provides a relatively straightforward auction process with a bidding timeline typically spanning a few days. Each listing is curated to focus on enthusiast cars and offers detailed photos, descriptions, and Carfax history reports (when available).
- Bring a Trailer auctions often include more extensive media, including comprehensive photo sets, videos, and detailed descriptions. BaT’s auctions are often characterized by a vibrant comment section where sellers, buyers, and enthusiasts interact, providing a unique social element to the buying process. This community engagement helps build trust and provides valuable insight for prospective buyers.
3. Vehicle Selection
- Cars & Bids primarily focuses on modern enthusiast vehicles, typically from the 1980s onward. If you’re searching for something unique from the past few decades, like a rare BMW M3 or a Toyota Land Cruiser, this platform is likely to cater to your taste.
- Bring a Trailer has a more diverse selection, featuring a blend of vintage classics, muscle cars, and exotic European models. BaT is often the place to go for iconic classics and well-preserved vintage finds, with a sprinkling of newer, rare performance cars.
4. Fees and Costs
The fee structures on both platforms are competitive but slightly different:
- Cars & Bids charges a flat 4.5% buyer’s fee (with a minimum of $225 and a maximum of $4,500). Sellers pay a one-time listing fee, which varies depending on the options chosen for the listing.
- Bring a Trailer charges a 5% buyer’s fee (capped at $5,000). The listing fee for sellers also varies, with options to enhance the listing with premium placements or featured spots. BaT’s slightly higher buyer’s fee reflects its longer-standing presence in the market and its extensive auction community.
5. Community and Engagement
Both platforms offer community engagement, but Bring a Trailer has developed a more robust network of active users who frequently comment, ask questions, and offer insights. This can help both buyers and sellers feel confident in the auction process. The comment section on BaT often adds value to the auction by providing context, expertise, and historical details on the vehicle.
Cars & Bids has a growing community and an active comment section but is generally seen as more streamlined and less intensive. If you prefer a simpler auction experience with less discussion, Cars & Bids may be more appealing.
6. User Interface and Usability
- Cars & Bids offers a simple, straightforward user interface that focuses on the essentials without unnecessary complexity. The site’s minimalist design is well-suited to quick browsing, with clear, easy-to-follow listings.
- Bring a Trailer, with its longer history, has a more feature-rich design. Users can navigate various categories and explore curated lists, adding to the experience. While the interface might feel slightly more complex, it appeals to users who enjoy a more in-depth browsing experience.
Conclusion: Which Platform is Right for You?
Ultimately, your choice between Cars & Bids and Bring a Trailer will depend on the type of vehicles you’re interested in, the level of community engagement you prefer, and how important a simple or feature-rich interface is to you. If you’re passionate about modern enthusiast cars and want a streamlined auction experience, Cars & Bids may be the ideal choice. However, if you appreciate a robust community and are interested in a mix of classic and collectible vehicles, Bring a Trailer is likely the better fit.
Some people might prefer building their own auction website, and host their own auctions, and for that some even prefer using an auction script, but if you want to make something professionally developed, read below as our agency can build it for you.
Interested in Building Your Own Car Auction Platform?
At Sitemile, we specialize in creating custom websites tailored to our clients’ unique visions. Whether you’re inspired by the streamlined approach of Cars & Bids or the community-driven model of Bring a Trailer, our team can build a site that captures the features and user experience you’re looking for. Reach out to us today to discuss how we can bring your concept to life! We specialise in building complex and specific auction websites.
Also read about building a website like bring a trailer (bat) or cars and bids.
